The Central Buckeye Conference announced its 2026 Softball All-Conference teams, honoring standout players from across the Kenton Trail and Mad River divisions after another strong spring season on the diamond.
Kenton Ridge’s Brenna Fyffe earned Kenton Trail Division Player of the Year honors, while North Union pitcher Leah Cox was named Mad River Division Player of the Year. Local schools, including Urbana, Bellefontaine, Benjamin Logan, Indian Lake, and Graham, were all represented among this year’s postseason selections.
Kenton Trail Division
Player of the Year: Brenna Fyffe, Kenton Ridge
First Team All-Conference
- Sophia Alt, London – Infield
- Morgan Boyd, Urbana – Infield
- Jayden Davis, Kenton Ridge – Infield
- Logan Donaldson, Jonathan Alder – Infield
- Addison Fox, Urbana – Outfield
- Brenna Fyffe, Kenton Ridge – Catcher
- Kendall Glass, Kenton Ridge – Outfield
- Kendall Massie, Kenton Ridge – Outfield
- Bailee Packer, Urbana – Catcher
- Ivee Rastatter, Kenton Ridge – Pitcher
- Addison Wical, Bellefontaine – Infield
Second Team All-Conference
- Lylli Ball, London – Outfield
- Lucy Boyd, Jonathan Alder – Outfield
- Chloe Easterday, Urbana – Outfield
- Annie Fincham, Kenton Ridge – Infield
- Joy Fogan, Bellefontaine – Infield
- Lily Foulk, Kenton Ridge – Infield
- Chloe Glass, Kenton Ridge – Outfield
- Maggie McCoy, Jonathan Alder – Catcher
- Rosie Timberlake, Jonathan Alder – Infield
- Kennedy Williams, Jonathan Alder – Infield
- Isla Wooten, Urbana – Pitcher
Special Mention
- Cara Cammon, Kenton Ridge
- Ava Dolan, Bellefontaine
- Morgan Hoffman, Urbana
- Kiera Matthews, Tecumseh
- Taryn Miller, Jonathan Alder
- Bella Peterman, London
Sportsmanship Award
- Destiney Childress, Tecumseh
- Annie Fincham, Kenton Ridge
- Chloe Heminger, Bellefontaine
- Owyn Johnson, Jonathan Alder
- Avery Kaup, London
- Maley Pine, Urbana
Mad River Division
Player of the Year: Leah Cox, North Union
First Team All-Conference
- Leah Cox, North Union – Pitcher
- Byanca Dubie, Shawnee – Outfield
- Ava George, Shawnee – Infield
- Adilynne Gregg, Benjamin Logan – Infield
- Kennedy Harrah, North Union – Infield
- Kale Keigley, North Union – Outfield
- Kailin McElroy, North Union – Catcher
- MacKenzie Miller, Indian Lake – Outfield
- Rylan Norviel, Benjamin Logan – Infield
- Julia Shaw, Northwestern – Infield
- Lily Wilson, Shawnee – Outfield
Second Team All-Conference
- Adalyn Beach, Shawnee – Infield
- Olivia Deane, Northwestern – Outfield
- Nicole Greene, Shawnee – Catcher
- Amara Hastings, Northwestern – Outfield
- Makayla Kibbe, Northwestern – Infield
- Brielle Kline, Benjamin Logan – Infield
- Tinlee Martino, North Union – Infield
- Emma McElroy, North Union – Outfield
- Sophia Pamer, Northwestern – Pitcher
- Addyson Plummer, Shawnee – Outfield
- Annie Rapp, Indian Lake – Infield
- Bre Wisener, Indian Lake – Outfield
Special Mention
- Malynn Bacher, Graham
- Kyler Carruthers, Indian Lake
- Rylee Fox, North Union
- Kelty Hannan, Shawnee
- Kylie Harner, Benjamin Logan
- Samantha Wolfe, Northwestern
Sportsmanship Award
- Sophia Fraley, Graham
- Adilynne Gregg, Benjamin Logan
- Emma Holland, Shawnee
- Ellee Hughes, Northwestern
- Hannah Johnson, Indian Lake
- Kailin McElroy, North Union
The all-conference selections recognize many of the top softball players in the Central Buckeye Conference this season for their performances at the plate, in the circle, and in the field throughout the 2026 campaign.
