The Central Buckeye Conference released its 2026 Baseball All-Conference teams, recognizing standout players from across the Kenton Trail and Mad River divisions following another competitive spring season.
Kenton Ridge’s Nic Stumpf earned Kenton Trail Division Player of the Year honors after helping lead the Cougars to a strong season, while Benjamin Logan’s Adam Tinsman was named Mad River Division Player of the Year. Area schools, including Urbana, Indian Lake, Graham, Benjamin Logan, and Bellefontaine, were well represented throughout the postseason honors.
Mad River Division
Player of the Year: Adam Tinsman, Benjamin Logan
First Team All-Conference
- Cayden Brown, Benjamin Logan – Outfield
- Micah Gregg, Benjamin Logan – Infield
- Brody Grimm, Northwestern – Catcher
- Jacob Hawley, Benjamin Logan – Pitcher
- Soli Hughes, Benjamin Logan – Outfield
- Nixon Lillard, Indian Lake – Infield
- Cash Mounts, Shawnee – Infield
- Kaiden Roeder, Shawnee – Infield
- Jaxon Snipes, Indian Lake – Pitcher
- Reed Strayer, Indian Lake – Outfield
- Adam Tinsman, Benjamin Logan – Pitcher
Second Team All-Conference
- Noah Belcher, Shawnee – Infield
- Christian Cooper, Shawnee – Catcher
- Logan Errett, Northwestern – Outfield
- Cooper Hall, Indian Lake – Infield
- Brody Jenkins, Graham – Outfield
- Jaxon Mabery, North Union – Infield
- Oliver Morse, Benjamin Logan – Infield
- Aaron Rapp, Indian Lake – Infield
- Cayden Rodgers, Shawnee – Pitcher
- Ried Smith, Northwestern – Outfield
- Jack Traylor, Graham – Infield
Special Mention
- Xaiver Allen, Benjamin Logan
- Greyson Bledsoe, North Union
- Nathan Crisler, Graham
- Brady Golliday, Indian Lake
- Nolan Hockett, Northwestern
- Hudson Kress, Shawnee
Sportsmanship Award
- Levi Hollingsworth, Graham
- Carson Kluczynski, Northwestern
- Jace Phipps, North Union
- Gavin Riedmiller, Benjamin Logan
- Kai Shaw, Shawnee
- Tyler Tidwell, Indian Lake
Kenton Trail Division
Player of the Year: Nic Stumpf, Kenton Ridge
First Team All-Conference
- Jake Bauer, Jonathan Alder – Pitcher
- Kevin Endres, Urbana – Pitcher
- Jakob Groeschel, Kenton Ridge – Outfield
- Grady Lantz, Urbana – Infield
- Cam Martin, Jonathan Alder – Infield
- Brennan Shaffer, Kenton Ridge – Infield
- Nic Stumpf, Kenton Ridge – Outfield
- Corey Taylor, Jonathan Alder – Pitcher
- Cashton Wheeler, Jonathan Alder – Outfield
- Carter Williams, Kenton Ridge – Catcher
- Cyrus Worley, Kenton Ridge – Infield
Second Team All-Conference
- Braden Collins, London – Outfield
- Julian Daniels, Kenton Ridge – Infield
- Devin Hammond, London – Pitcher
- Carter Houseman, Urbana – Outfield
- Colin Nickell, London – Outfield
- Eli Noble, London – Infield
- Reid Olinger, Tecumseh – Infield
- Braxton Overmyer, Jonathan Alder – Catcher
- Mason Petersheim, Jonathan Alder – Pitcher
- Silas Shoemaker, Jonathan Alder – Infield
- Hunter Tuttle, Kenton Ridge – Infield
Special Mention
- Mason Amato, Kenton Ridge
- Garrett Bauer, Jonathan Alder
- Braxton Brown, London
- Carter Olinger, Tecumseh
- BJ Potter, Urbana
- Patrick Stolly, Bellefontaine
Sportsmanship Award
- DJ Blaine, Tecumseh
- Jack Carter, London
- Broderick Donahoe, Urbana
- Grady Gruber, Kenton Ridge
- Evan Reynard, Jonathan Alder
- Spencer Stolly, Bellefontaine
The selections highlight some of the top baseball talent across the Central Buckeye Conference this spring, recognizing players for their performances on the mound, at the plate, and in the field throughout the 2026 season.
